efms Migration Report
November 2005 | | | | |
EU: Tenth meeting of the
"Euro-Mediterranean Partnership" On 27-28 November 2005, the 25
EU Heads of State and Government met with government officials of ten non-European states
bordering the Mediterranean to celebrate the tenth annually held Euromed Summit of the
"Euro-Mediterranean-Partnership", also referred to as Barcelona Process, which
was established in 1995. In the detailed work programme for the next five years, which was
adopted at the end of the conference by the 35 Euromed-States, the participants of the summit
have stressed their interest to closely cooperate in the areas of migration and illegal
immigration. This cooperation includes the promotion of legal immigration and the
improvement of measures to fight against illegal migration and trafficking in human beings.
SZ 03.11.05 // Handelsblatt 24.11.05 // NZZ 25.11.05 // FTD
25.11.05 // FAZ 29.11.05
EU Commission: Initiative
against illegal immigration On 30 November 2005, the EU Commission published
a communication to the Ministerial Council and the European Parliament as a first step
towards a "coherent, comprehensive and balanced" European migration policy. It
is foreseen to establish joint coastal patrols in the Mediterranean, to set up expert teams that
are available at short notice to provide technical and operational support for Member States
facing sudden migration problems, to found an special solidarity fund to support countries
bordering the Mediterranean which are particularly affected by migration flows as well as to
establish a early warning system allowing for an improved exchange of information among
the European officials stationed in the most important countries of origin and transit for
migrants. FR 14.11.05 // FAZ 01.12.05 // SZ 01.12.05 // taz
01.12.05 // NZZ 01.12.05
EU report on xenophobia
and discrimination of minorities On 23 November 2005, the European Monitoring
Centre on Racism and Xenophobia (EUMC) published its report on racism and xenophobia.
According to the report, minorities living in the European Union are particularly often subject
to discrimination. The about 8 million Roma form the group that is affected most. However,
also citizens of Muslim belief, labour migrants from Africa, Middle East and Latin America
are affected. taz 24.11.05 // FR 24.11.05
Böhmer new
parliamentary undersecretary for integration On 29 November 2005, the Federal
government appointed Prof. Maria Böhmer (CDU) as parliamentary undersecretary for
integration at the Federal Chancellery and as new Federal Government Commissioner for
Migration, Refugees und Integration. With her appointment, the 55-year-old professor for
educational theory from Rhineland-Palatinate succeeds Marieluise Beck (party of
Bündnis 90/The Greens). According to Böhmer, the appointment as minister for
integration at the Federal Chancellery constitutes an important upgrade of this office.
taz 23.11.05 // FR-aktuell 23.11.05 // Press release of the integration
commissioner 29.11.05 // Die Welt 01.12.05
New representative of the
UN High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) in Germany From 1 December
2005, Gottfried Köfner, who at the moment still represents the UNHCR in Vienna, will
be the new UNHCR representative in Berlin. With this appointment he substitutes Stefan
Berglund, who has been representing the UNHCR in Germany since 2002 and who will go
into retirement. Press release of UNHCR 11.11.05
Riots in Paris: Problems
with integration in France unleash a debate in Germany The severe riots that broke
out on 27 October 2005 in the suburbs of Paris which are home to immigrants from North and
Black Africa spread within a few days to 274 communities throughout France and lasted three
weeks. The cause of these riots was a fatal accident suffered by two migrant youths who tried
to escape from the police in Clichy-sous-Bois near Paris. On 8 November 2005, the French
government declared the state of emergency, which meanwhile was prolonged to remain in
force until 14 February 2006. In the course of the upheavals, schools, kindergartens and shops
were damaged or destroyed; around 10,000 cars were set on fire and 3,000 youths were
arrested. For the time being, German politicians, migration experts and representatives of
immigration groups do not expect similar riots to take place in Germany too, stating that in
Germany, a degree of segregation as high as and comparable to that observed in French cities
would not exist. However, they were jointly warning of underestimating the disastrous
situation on the German vocational training and labour market and the threats that are linked
to the emerging disintegration. The new Federal Minister of the Interior, Wolfgang
Schäuble (CDU), emphasized that the integration of immigrants would be one focal
point of emphasis for the new Federal government. FTD 03.11.05
// taz 07.11.05 // Handelsblatt (online) 07.11.05 // FTD 08.11.05 // FAZ 08.11.05 // NZZ
09.11.05 // Press release of the Federal government (online) 10.11.05 // Wiener Zeitung
(online) 10.11.05 // Die Zeit 10.11.05 // FR 11.11.05
Fictitious paternities to
become punishable The ministers of justice of the Federal government and the
federal states have announced that they will fight against the misuse of declarations of
paternity to obtain residence titles and social welfare payments surreptitiously. Background:
in Germany, natural paternity does not constitute a requirement for recognition. Moreover,
fictitious paternities have been exempt from punishment so far. In the future, the Youth
Welfare Offices will be given the right to contest declarations of paternities before a family
court. In such case, the court will then have to check if a relationship exists between father
and child and/or if he is the natural father. The Federal Minister of Justice, Mrs Zypries
(SPD), emphasized that binational couples where "the husband looks after the child,
educates him or her, takes care or pays the child"s maintenance" would not be affected
by the new provision. The party Bündnis 90/The Greens and the German Lawyers"
Association (DAV), however, have expressed their doubts, arguing that the right of avoidance
would generally make suspect all foreign parents not possessing a secure residence status.
Der Spiegel 14.11.05 // SZ 18.11.05
Geschwister-Scholl-Prize:
German-Turkish author honoured for her commitment On 14 November 2005,
Necla Kelek was awarded the Geschwister-Scholl-Prize in Munich, which is endowed with
10,000 euros. She was awarded the Prize by the German Publishers and Booksellers
Association and the City of Munich for her book titled "The Alien Bride". In her
book, the 47-years-old Sociologist of Turkish origin, who is living in Berlin, addresses the
issue of forced marriages between Turkish girls with Turkish husbands in Germany.
NN 14.11.05 // taz 15.11.05 // FAZ 20.11.05
Turkish Foreign Minister
advocates integration in Germany On the occasion of his visit to Berlin, the Turkish
Foreign Minister, Abdullah Gül, emphasised that the home country of the Turks living
in Germany would be first of all Germany. In order to achieve full integration, they should
learn German well and participate in the social, economic and political life. This statement
has led to thorough discussions within the Turkish community. "This is a direct
guideline for what to do", says Eren Unsal, spokeswoman of the Turkish Association,
and added that she was happy that Gül made such a clear statement in favour of
integration. This would encourage many people to take advantage of integration offers such
as German language courses. BZ 21.11.05 // Die Welt (online)
23.11.05
North Rhine Westphalia:
Rigorous deportation practice criticised Refugees" and social welfare associations
have criticised an ordinance issued by the interior minister of North Rhine-Westphalia, Ingo
Wolf (FDP), at the beginning of September according to which protection against deportation
should be only taken into consideration in case of "extraordinarily severe physical or
psychological defects or threats to a person"s health that are of vital significance". The
ordinance would not stipulate when a case of "threats to a person"s health of vital
significance" would exist nor would it regulate who is in charge of determining it.
Therefore, the associations suspect that it will be left to the aliens authorities" discretion how
to proceed. There would be an ever increasing number of seriously ill and suicidal refugees
who are deported to their home countries from Düsseldorf. Persons obliged to leave the
country and who are suffering from health problems would have to undergo repeated medical
examinations until they were finally found to be capable of being returned by plane. In the
context of this practice, it would be striking that a particular group of medical practitioners
would be in charge of conducting the medical examinations nationwide. There would be also
an increase in the number of refugee children of age, who have been raised in Germany and
who would be deported despite the fact that their parents have the right of residence. In such
cases, the parents would be recommended to leave Germany together with their children on a
voluntary basis. dpa 09.11.05 // SZ 19.11.05
Headscarf bans in
Baden-Württemberg (kindergartens) and North Rhine-Westphalia (schools) under
way On 30 November 2005, the local parliament of Baden-Württemberg
discussed the first reading of a bill for a general headscarf ban that is to become also
applicable for nursery school teachers. The bill follows the provisions of the headscarf ban
for teachers that are already established in the School Law. Gabriele
Müller-Trimbusch, head of the social services department of the city of Stuttgart,
complained that the new law was to govern issues, which - particularly in larger cities -
would not exist. In Stuttgart, where 30 Muslim nursery school teachers wear headscarves at
work, it has proved to be worthwhile in practice to issue guidelines on the basis of which the
personnel undertakes to adhere to educational principles that are in line with the Constitution.
The dispute on the headscarf ban between a Muslim nursery school teacher and the city of
Eberbach, located in Baden-Württemberg, was settled before the labour court of
Stuttgart by making a compromise. The nursery school teacher received a compensation in
the amount of 8,000 euros and accepted in return the termination of her employment on 31
August 2005 (Ref.: 27 Ca 373/05). In North Rhine-Westphalia, the government coalition
composed of CDU and FDP is also drafting a bill introducing a headscarf ban for Muslim
teachers working at schools. The Central Council of Muslims announced to take actions
against the bill. dpa 09.11.05 // Das Parlament 14.11.05 // Die
Welt 29.11.05
Baden-Württemberg: First report of hardship commission Since its first
meeting in September 2005, the hardship commission of the federal state of
Baden-Württemberg has met three times so far. According to its chairman, Edgar
Wais, 700 applications for examination of a total of 2,800 persons have been filed
meanwhile. Eighty per cent of the applications were filed by migrants from ex-Yugoslavia
and 20 per cent by persons of North African or Arab origin. In one out of five cases, the
commission recommended to grant the right of residence. One third of the applications
examined, however, would have no chance to be accepted as the persons in question could
not provide evidence of any integration efforts undertaken. Positive consideration would be
given to persons who do not depend on welfare payments but who earn their own living, who
have learned German and who have not called the attention of the police in a negative way. In
four cases, the commission recommended to grant the right of residence only to individual
family members. So far, interior minister Heribert Rech (CDU) has decided on only four
applications and accepted three of them. dpa 11.11.05
Rhineland-Palatinate:
Unique project in Germany to support refugees willing to return The federal state of
Rhineland-Palatinate makes available five million euros to support refugees with concrete
assistance in the form of money or technical equipment to allow them a new start in their
home countries. On behalf of the Ministry of the Interior, advisers of the social welfare
organisation Diakonisches Werk in the city of Trier will offer consultancy services to
municipalities on how to deal with difficult cases over the next three years. "The vast
majority of the refugees would actually like to return to their home countries" says Rita
Behrens, one of the project advisers. However, these refugees could not return "with
their heads raised if they don"t bring back something valuable". Such return would
mean a loss of face. In cases where negotiations between refugees obliged to leave the
country and aliens" authorities have come to a halt, offering relatively simple equipment, such
as a high-quality sewing machine for establishing a tailor"s shop, could often help solve the
problems. dpa 07.11.05
Hesse: Low voter-turnout
in elections to Aliens" Advisory Boards Of the 470,000 foreigners entitled to vote in
the federal state of Hesse, only 38,000 went to the polls to elect the new Aliens" Advisory
Boards on 27 November 2005. In Frankfurt, where about one fourth of the persons entitled to
vote are registered, voter-turnout was as low as 5.7 per cent and hence clearly below average.
Hüseyin Sitki, Chairman of the local foreigners" representation body of Frankfurt, was
very disappointed that turnout at the election was that low despite the strong pre-election
publicity. FR 30.11.05
Thuringia: Deported
Vietnamese family allowed returning to Germany A Vietnamese woman, who was
deported in February 2004 together with her three children, is allowed to return to Germany
for humanitarian reasons. The German embassy in Vietnam has found out that the children,
who were born in Germany, were not able to integrate themselves. In the course of the past
months, citizens of Bleicherode (District of Nordhausen) and school mates have organised
pickets and demonstrations to demand the right of the family to return. Now, the decision to
issue residence permits is to the discretion of the Aliens Authority of Nordhausen.
Die Welt 19.11.05
Bavaria: Asylum seekers
will be exempted from paying textbook fees for children Like the payees of housing
benefits or the so-called unemployment benefits II, asylum seekers living in Bavaria will be
exempt in future from paying schoolbook fees. On 24 November 2005, the Education
Committee of the Bavarian parliament adopted unanimously a corresponding motion of the
Greens. SZ 25.11.05
State of Bavaria reduces
subsidies for integration Charitable organisations such as the Caritas Association,
Diakonie, Bavarian Red Cross and German Non-Denominational Welfare Association have
expressed complaints that not only the Federal government but also the state of Bavaria
would increasingly reduce their share in the financing of integration measures. According to
Caritas, the state of Bavaria reduced the funds contributed to the social counselling of foreign
nationals by 65 per cent in the year 2004. Instead of the previous 380,000 euros, Caritas
would now receive just 81,000 euros. Also the contributions paid for the counselling of late
German repatriates (Spätaussiedler) were cut by 15 per cent. SZ 08.11.05
Munich: Rejected asylum
seeker caught in no man"s land for seven months Since 6 April 2005, the Iraqi
national Burhan Karim Zangana of Kurdish origin has been detained at Stadelheim and
Munich airport without any judicial order. According to the police, however, he is not kept in
custody. His asylum application was rejected in an expedited procedure. Due to missing
documentation, he is not allowed to enter Germany; for the same reason, however, he is also
not able to leave the country. His urgent appeal for permission to enter Germany filed in
August at the administrative court, has so far not been decided upon. Zangana"s lawyer,
Michael Sack, has lodged appeals at the courts of Erding, Landshut and Munich. His
reasoning: Deprivation of liberty without judicial order constitutes a violation of the German
Basic Law. Moreover, a refugee may be detained within the so-called Airport Procedure for a
maximum term of 19 days only. SZ 04.11.05 // SZ 09.11.05 // SZ
29.11.05
Federal Constitutional
Court: Residence rights of children of foreigners strengthened The constitutional
complaint filed by a Turkish child living with his/her father in Germany against the denial of
a residence permit has been successful. In future, children of foreign nationals who were born
in Germany may obtain residence permits even in case only the father possesses such a secure
legal status. On 25 November 2005, the Federal Constitutional Court (BVerfG) declared
unconstitutional the Act stipulating that the rights of a child would exclusively depend on the
status of his or her mother, arguing that this provision would constitute an infringement of the
principle of equal treatment (German Basic Law, Art. 3, paragraph 3, sentence 1) and ordered
an amendment to be introduced by the law making bodies by 31 December 2006. The equal
treatment of mother and father would be possible and necessary for the child"s sake.
Decisions on appeals lodged by children referring to the right of residence of their father
would have to be postponed until the amendment of the law in question has entered into force
(Ref.: 2 BvR 524/01). Press release of the Federal Constitutional
Court 25.11.05 // Die Welt 26.11.05 // SZ 26.11.05
Federal Administrative
Court: Fundamental decision on the revocation of the right of asylum in case of political
changes On 1 November 2005, the Federal Administrative Court (BVerwG)
decided that the recognition of persons suffering political persecution as persons entitled to
asylum and as refugees is in principle revocable (Ref.: 1 C 21.04). As a prerequisite, the
conditions prevailing in the home country would need to have changed considerably and
permanently and it needed to be possible to rule out with reasonable certainty that the reasons
having substantially caused the person to leave the country will not re-emerge. Objections
like threats of general nature could not be raised. The UN High Commissioner for Refugees
(UNHCR) criticised that, according to the Geneva Convention on Refugees, returning
refugees needed to be efficiently protected by the authorities of their home countries. In
addition, the decision would split up the provisions for the international protection of
refugees in Germany. The example of Iraq would illustrate this: While the Conference of
Interior Ministers would consider a return of refugee as unreasonable due to the ongoing
existence of general threats, at the same time thousands of Iraqi nationals would lose their
recognition as refugees. This would bring about the risk of a de facto loss of the legal
residence status and of losing a job or a vocational training place. Press release of the Federal Administrative Court 01.11.05 // FAZ 02.11.05 //
NZ 03.11.05 // UNHCR (online) 03.11.05
Asylum statistics
In November 2005, a total of 2,464 persons have submitted an application for political
asylum in Germany. Compared to October, the number of asylum seekers has thus increased
by 9.7 per cent (+217 persons). Compared to November 2004, respective figures have fallen
by 7.5 per cent (-201 persons). The main countries of origin in November were Serbia and
Montenegro (429), Iraq (200) and Turkey (186) followed by Syria (133) and the Russian
Federation (129). In November 2005, the Federal Office for Migration and Refugees has
reviewed the applications of 4,960 asylum seekers, 34 (0.7 per cent) of whom have been
recognised as entitled to political asylum. A further 150 persons (3.0 per cent) have been
granted protection against deportation according to §60, paragraph 1, Residence Act.
The applications of 3,161 people (63.7 per cent) have been rejected. The cases of another
1,615 persons (32.6 per cent) have been closed for other reasons, for example because asylum
seekers have withdrawn their applications. Press release BMI of
06.12.05
November 2005 | | | | |
|