|
|
efms Migration Report
June 2007 | | | | |
EU Commission tries to
define rules on how to deal with boat refugees
By defining guidelines on how to deal with shipwrecked refugees, the EU Commission
wants to overcome problems that are due to unclear responsibilities as regards the reception
of such refugees. Open issues regarding the question of which Member State would be in
charge of these refugees not only lead to tensions between the EU Member States but also
cause refugees again and again to face serious or even life-threatening situations. According
to refugee reports, it repeatedly happened that ships passing by people in distress would
ignore these persons and that some bordering countries would deny ships to enter their ports
which have rescued refugees on board. This happened despite the fact that the international
maritime law required from every captain firstly to rescue people in distress and secondly
from every surrounding state to allow rescued persons to go ashore, criticised Stefan Schmidt,
a member of the recently founded association "borderline-europe - Menschenrechte
ohne Grenzen (human rights without borders). Borderline-europe"s aim is to inform about the
misery of refugees at the EU"s external borders, which in the opinion of the organisation is
due to the repeal of the international maritime and human rights laws by the practice in the
EU. By setting up guidelines, the EU Commission wants to define criteria under which boat
refugees are to be rescued and which Member State would afterwards be obliged to let them
go ashore. In addition, EU Commissioner Franco Frattini appealed to the Member States to
finally provide the equipment promised to the border protection agency Frontex in order to
allow special rescue operations to be implemented. Instead of the foreseen 115 ships, 25
helicopters and 23 aircraft, Frontex would currently dispose of only 20 ships and four
helicopters. FR 05.06.07 // IHT 07.06.07 // FAZ 08.06.07 // SZ
10.06.07 // taz online 20.06.07
UNHCR: Actions taken by
the BAMF are not in accordance with the Geneva Refugee Conventions
According to UNHCR spokesman Stefan Telöken, the United Nation"s High
Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) has criticised actions taken by the Federal Office for
Migration and Refugees (BAMF) as regards Iraqi refugees saying that they are in accordance
with the Geneva Refugee Conventions. Recently, the BAMF has deprived many Iraqi
nationals of their asylum status, arguing that extremely threatening situations would no
longer have to be expected after the fall of Saddam Hussein. In 2006, 18,000 Iraqi nationals
were affected by the revocation of their asylum status. Some of them are now living in
Germany without secure residence status. According to the Refugee Conventions, however,
lasting and stable changes needed to prevail in a country of origin before persons could be
deprived of their refugee status. Yet, this would not be the case in Iraq, according to
Telöken. In another report, the UNHCR calls for more instead of less protection to be
offered to Iraqi refugees. The increase in the worldwide number of refugees in 2006 (9.9
million international refugees, 1.2 million more than in 2005), which in the opinion of the
UNHCR is due to the war in Iraq, would be another evidence supporting the demands of the
High Commissioner. In the past year, about 1.5 million Iraqi nationals were seeking
protection outside Iraq. The BAMF, however, replied to these critics already in past May by
stopping its revocation practice for certain groups of persons from Iraq, such as members of
religious minorities as for example Christians, Mandaens and Yazidis. Excluded from this
halt are persons such as criminals or others threatening Germany"s internal security.
BZ 20.06.07 // taz 28.06.07 // Migration Report 2006
Expansion of deserts as a
cause for migration flows According to a report of the United Nations, a future
increase in the number of refugees is to be expected due to the expansion of deserts and the
destruction of settlement areas caused by it. According to the report, the Sahel region in
Africa but also regions in Central Asia are particularly threatened. Currently, as many as 100
to 200 million would be already affected by the expansion of the deserts so that estimations
expect about 50 million more refugees within the next ten years. The report assumes that only
a small proportion of them will have the opportunity to escape to Europe and that most of the
migration flows will move within the continents affected. SZ
29.06.07 // Die Welt 29.06.07
Reform of the Immigration
Act passes the Federal Parliament Despite harsh criticism by the opposition parties
and some Nays from among the social democrats (SPD), the German Bundestag, the Federal
Parliament, has adopted on 14 June 2007 the law on the implementation of the directives of
the European Union regulating residence and asylum law affairs. By amending the law,
eleven EU directives are to be transposed into national law. Inter alia, the rights to remain of
tolerated foreigners are to be regulated, the subsequent immigration of spouses will be subject
to stricter regulations, and the demand for a stronger active integration of foreigners will be
stressed. While the CDU party was satisfied with the amendments, the SPD considered them
a painful compromise. The opposition parties comprising the FDP, the Left Party and the
Greens complained that the amendments would restrict the law in force considerably.
Especially criticised were the new regulations governing the subsequent immigration of
spouses according to which the spouse who wants to immigrate needs to be at least 18 years
old and has to have a basic knowledge of the German language in order to be allowed to
immigrate to Germany. The aim behind this provision, according to the government, is to
better protect women against forced marriages. The Left Party criticised that the instrument
actually most effective against forced marriages, an independent right of residence, would not
be introduced. Josef Winkler (of the Greens) called the regulation an "anti-Turkey
clause" as the majority of those coming to join their spouses would be of Turkish origin
and the requirements to be fulfilled would not be applicable to persons willing to immigrate
from other countries. According to Sybille Schreiber, expert of the women"s association Terre
de Femmes, the aim of impeding forced marriages would be an "alibi argument"
of Interior Minister Wolfgang Schäuble (CDU). hib-meldungen Bundestag 13.06.07 // SZ 14.06.07 // taz 14.06.07 // FR
15.06.07 // FAZ 15.06.07 // Das Parlament 18.06.07 // NN 19.06.07
Introduction of a score
system for regulating the immigration of highly-qualified workers being discussed
In the debate about opening Germany for the immigration of highly-qualified workers, the
possibility of introducing a score system as a means of regulation is being discussed. In his
reply to an inquiry of the MoP Sybille Laurischk of the FDP party, Federal Interior Minister
Wolfgang Schäuble (CDU) said that the Federal Government could possibly imagine
the introduction of a score system. Such system would allow to rate potential immigrants
according to "utility criteria", such as vocational training background and
language skills. This would offer the advantage of allowing the government to select new
immigrants in a target-oriented manner. Employers" associations and even trade unions are in
favour of such a system. Member of Parliament Dieter Wiefelspütz (SPD) said that he
could get to like such system as it enabled the state to further control immigration. Federal
Education Minister, Annette Schavan (CDU) also stressed that Germany needed to become
interesting for the "world"s best minds". taz 08.06.07 //
taz online 12.06.07 // Handelsblatt 13.06.07 // Der Spiegel 18.06.07 // SZ 26.06.07 // BZ
27.06.07 // Tagesspiegel 27.06.07
Federal Government
provides more funds for integration courses On 27 June 2007, Federal Interior
Minister Wolfgang Schäuble (CDU) presented to the Federal Government a report on
the effectiveness of the integration courses. On this occasion, he announced an increase of the
funds to be provided for 2008 - in future, 154.8 million euros will be made available for
integration courses, which is 14 million euros more than available so far. With this increase,
the refund rate paid by the Federal Office for Migration and Refugees to the institutions
offering the courses per participant and lesson to finance the integration courses will be
increased by 15 per cent to an amount of 2.35 euros. In addition, the number of participants
will be limited to 20 persons and a transparent competition in terms of quality among the
1,500 institutions offering courses will be promoted. Schäuble plans to introduce these
changes in the second half of 2007 by amending the ordinance governing the implementation
of integration courses. Press release of BMI 27.06.07 // FAZ
28.06.07
Chances to gain right to
remain for refugees only tolerated so far are most likely in Southern Germany A
comparison of information on the granting of rights to remain provided by the Interior
Ministers and Senators of the federal states has revealed that tolerated foreigners seem to
have best chances to be granted the right to remain in the federal states in Southern Germany,
which are otherwise known for their strict foreigners" policy. According to the report, Bavaria
- with a granting rate of 31.5 per cent - has so far granted the largest number of applicants a
limited right to remain. Tolerated persons would have also relatively good chances on a
successful petition in the federal states of Hesse, Baden-Württemberg and
Rhineland-Palatinate. With a granting rate of 2.72 per cent, the Saarland follows the strictest
granting policy. The Bavarian Interior Minister Günther Beckstein (CSU) was satisfied
with the implementation of the regulation governing the right to remain and added that in
Bavaria the provisions on the right to remain would not be applied in a harassing but in a
generous way. SZ 26.06.07
Support programme to stop
the outflow of persons from Eastern Germany A new support programme of the
Federal Government is to reduce the outflow of persons, and particularly of young women,
from Eastern Germany. Wolfgang Tiefensee (SPD), Federal Minister of Transport, Building
and Urban Development, has announced plans to implement in an initial phase pilot projects
in two regions in Eastern Germany in order to find out how it is possible to maintain supply
structures in sparsely populated areas. Among other measures to be supported are projects on
the mobile provision of health services, multi-generation housing projects, mobile libraries
and bus services on demand. Stephan Hilsberg, MoP of the SPD from Eastern Germany, said
that the plans of Mr Tiefensee sounded like a joke against the background of the demographic
forecasts for certain regions. Even though such plans would not be bad, they would not be far
reaching enough. Hilsberg asked Tiefensee to pay attention to the impoverishment potentials
existing in some regions as many young men would have lost meanwhile any contact to the
rest of the society. BZ 04.06.07
Again immigration of Jews
from the former Soviet Union Following a factual immigration stop over the last
two and a half years, immigration of so-called Jewish quota refugees from the former Soviet
Union can take place again, even though under stricter conditions. In 2005 already, the
Central Committee of the Jews, the Union of Progressive Jews and the Interior Ministers of
the federal states agreed on new immigration provisions. However, they could not be
employed before the entering into force of the 7th law on the amendment of the Federal
Expellees Act adopted on 16 May 2007. In future, the Federal Office for Migration and
Refugees (BAMF) will be in charge of implementing the provisions, and no longer the
Federal Ministry of the Interior together with the federal states. As a prerequisite for entering
Germany, positive "integration forecasts" are needed now, which are drawn up by
the BAMF on the basis of a score system to assess the immigrants. This system is to evaluate,
inter alia, if the immigrants are able to earn their livings in order not to depend on the
payment of welfare benefits. Moreover, the Central Welfare Office of the Jews - in
cooperation with the Union of Progressive Jews - needs to confirm that the applicants will be
accepted in a Jewish community. Joachim Waldenmeier of the BAMF expects 2,000 - 5,000
Jewish immigrants to come per year. The President of the Central Committee of the Jews,
Paul Spiegel, considered the agreement found in 2005 to be a fair compromise. Jüdische Allgemeine 28.06.07 //
www.infonet-frsh.de/fileadmin/infonet/pdf/ BMI_HinweiseAendGesetz.pdf
Tensions in
Christian-Islamic dialogue The position of the Christian churches in Germany
towards Islam seems to have hardened: both, representatives of the Protestant Church and of
the Catholic Church expressed a feeling of uneasiness about the current intent of Islamic
institutions in Germany to obtain the status of a public corporation. Cardinal Lehmann, for
example, warned about treating all religious communities in Germany equally and to grant
the status of being a public corporation "relatively randomly". In the past, the
Protestant Bishop Huber has expressed his understanding for criticism on certain construction
plans for mosques. The differences between the Protestant Church of Germany ("EKD" in its
German abbreviation) and leading representatives of Islam are mainly due to a handout titled
"Klarheit und Gute Nachbarschaft" (Clarity and good vicinity) published by the
EKD in November 2006. There, the differences between the two religions are outlined and
Islam is criticised. At a meeting between the EKD and the Coordination Committee of
Muslims ("KRM" in its German abbreviation) at the Yavuz-Sultan-Selim mosque in
Mannheim on 30 May 2007, no agreement could be reached on controversial standpoints. In a
statement of the KRM it was said that the paper contained inappropriate generalizations and
"pure scaremongering". Huber countered that the paper constituted an urgently
needed differentiation and Muslims would with no word be suspected in general. On the
occasion of the Protestants" Church Day held in Cologne from 6 - 10 June 2007, Bekir
Alboga, commissioner of the Turkish institute for religion Ditib, complained about the
existence of a "strained relation". Representatives of both religions, however,
stressed that the dialogue needed to be continued. 21.06.07 // taz
22.06.07
CDU: Discussion on
migration issues The Christian-Democratic Union (CDU) seems to change its
positions as regards migration issues. On the one hand, this can be clearly seen in the area of
integration: in a draft programme of the CDU there is the talk of Germany being a country of
integration. All citizens benefited from a successful integration and controlled immigration,
both in the economy and at work as well as in daily social life. Moreover, in one paragraph of
the basic programme of the CDU party it is said that the state under the rule of law and Islam
are basically compatible. Within the party, however, there is disagreement on the immigration
of highly-qualified workers. Federal Minister Schavan, for example, expressed herself in
favour of facilitating immigration. Especially the minimum salary requirement of 85.000
euros annually foreseen by the Immigration Act would be too high. The chairman of the
Union party, Volker Kauder, however, declared in contrast that first of all the immigrants
already living here and youths without school leaving degree needed to be qualified in a
better way and added that he would agree with the Federal Minister only on the issue of
taking measures against the current lack of highly-qualified workers. FAZ 28.06.07 // Die Welt 29.06.07
Berlin: First immigration
summit in the German capital On 22 June 2007, the first integration summit in
Berlin was held with the participation of senators and secretaries of state from all Berlin
administration departments of the Senate, who had been invited by Berlin"s Mayor, Klaus
Wowereit (SPD). He presented the integration concept of the "red-red coalition"
to the almost 500 participants: 45 core projects aim at reducing the disadvantages migrants
face at work, school or in social life. The goals achieved in the area of integration will be
revised and summarised in reports on an annual basis. Most important goal would be to
improve the opportunities of migrants as regards finding vocational training and work places,
said Wowereit. Even though it would be an encouraging signal that meanwhile almost 18 per
cent of the young migrants would finish school with an university entrance qualification
(Abitur), which corresponds to an increase of 6 per cent since the year 2000, the total number
would still be much too small. Some representatives of migrant associations were rather
sceptical about the outcomes of the integration summit. Celal Altun of the Turkish
Community of Berlin said that his organisation would not expect any substantial results. Also
Jens-Uwe Thomas, representing the Refugee Council, was convinced that the integration
paper would contain only non-binding declarations of intent. In contrast, the Vice-President
of the Islamic Federation of Berlin (IFB), Burhan Kesici, said that his association would use
the summit to foster contacts and hoped to intensify the cooperation with other migrant
organisations. BZ 22.06.07 // BZ 22.06.07 // SZ
23.06.07
Asylum statistics
In June 2007, a total of 1,241 persons has submitted a petition for political asylum in
Germany. The figure constitutes a decrease of 7.9 per cent (-106 persons) compared to May
2007. Compared to June 2006, the number of asylum seekers has declined by 17.5 per cent
(-263 persons). In June, the main countries of origin were Serbia (138), Iraq (135), Turkey
(119), Vietnam (81) and the Russian Federation (78).In this month, the Federal Office for
Migration and Refugees decided on 2,084 asylum applications. Twenty-eight persons (1.3 per
cent) were recognised as being entitled to political asylum. Another 284 persons (13.6 per
cent) were granted protection against deportation according to § 60, paragraph 1,
Residence Act.The applications of 1,090 persons (52.3 per cent) have been rejected. The
cases of a further 643 persons (30.9 per cent) have been closed for other reasons (e.g. due to
suspensions of asylum procedures because persons have withdrawn their applications).
Press release of BMI 09.07.07
June
2007 | | | | |
|
|